What's your favorite Cincinnati made ice cream, Graeter's, United Dairy Farmers or Alglamesis?The opinions expressed here are those of the individual and not those of StreetAdvisor. Report
Graeter's has the best flavor. It is rich tasting and decadent, especially the flavors with chocolate "chips" (more like chunks). If you're going to indulge in ice crea, save yourself for some Graeter's.
Graeter's has the best ice cream in Cincinnati. It is rich, creamy and delicious and made in small batches. Aglamesis' ice cream is made in a similar manner, but they use gelatin in their ice cream and Graeter's does not. United Dairy Farmers (UDF) is okay, but it is definitely made using a more industrial method (hence it being cheaper and not as good, in my opinion.) Since ice cream should be a splurge, why not get the best and go with Graeter's. Of course, as all three of these are local businesses, supporting any of them would be a neighborly thing to do. Also, "U.S. News & World Report" just ranked Graeter's as the 6th best ice cream spot in the country!
Christine Schiefer 2yrs+
My favorite has to be United Dairy Farmers because I love their flavors and it's much more affordable than Graeter's and Aglamesis Bros.! There are also many UDF locations and they have convenient hours. Graeter's was always a little too fatty-tasting, in my opinion, so I'd rather go for UDF, which is also much cheaper.