Should Staten Island Secede from NYC?

They're talking about this again!

http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=940DE2DC1638F931A25751C1A96E948260

What does everyone think about SI going on its own? Do they benefit from staying part of NYC, or not? And what would the effect be on the city as a whole?
The opinions expressed here are those of the individual and not those of StreetAdvisor.
8 people following
this discussion
Report

12 Comments

AdamS 2yrs+
That's a fantastic read hudson. Not long ago, I didn't know what the word "Secede" meant. That was until I recently saw an episode of Boston Legal where Massachusetts wanted to Secede from the USA because it did not feel the USA would protect Massachusetts in a time of war.

It was a very interesting episode, and I had no idea that the concept existed where a state, city or otherwise can effectively vote to leave the greater area.

Anyways, the case in the episode was nothing more than a political boost for Massachusetts, and really had nothing to do with wanting to secede from the USA. That's what makes this article so interesting to me.

This seems like a real genuine case where the locals really want to leave NYC. I wonder if this is representative of the whole though of Staten Island though?

As a local New Yorker, what do you think hudson? I don't know too much about Staten Island, although I do know it's where the rubbish is dumped quite often.

A very interesting read, thanks hudson.

AJ
Report
The opinions expressed here are those of the individual and not those of StreetAdvisor.
hudson 2yrs+
Y'welcome.

I have been to Staten Island exactly twice - once to visit a friend of my ex, and once to visit Snug Harbor. It is nice enough, but it does not feel like NYC at all. I really have no reason to go there, and if the folks from Staten Island want to be on their own, then maybe they should.

Is there anyone here actually from Staten Island? What do you all think?
Report
The opinions expressed here are those of the individual and not those of StreetAdvisor.
CommunityMan 2yrs+
I saw that episode of BL too - very funny. But seriously, what would the effect be on the people of SI and the whole of NYC? How would people benefit?
Report
The opinions expressed here are those of the individual and not those of StreetAdvisor.
cmsv 2yrs+
NYC would have one less place to dump garbage. And SI would probably have to figure out which side of the Port Authority they belong to.
Report
The opinions expressed here are those of the individual and not those of StreetAdvisor.
Uraniumfish 2yrs+
Yes! Though they should still somehow accept our garbage...
Report
The opinions expressed here are those of the individual and not those of StreetAdvisor.
hhusted 2yrs+
I've only been to Staten Island once and to me I do not care if they become independent or not. It is a decision that their poltical leaders will have to decide. Shouldn't there be a vote on this?
Report
The opinions expressed here are those of the individual and not those of StreetAdvisor.
BroadwayBK 2yrs+
Why do I feel like if Staten Is seceded, they would probably charge us more to go over the Verrazano?

I say we keep them; what a fabulous dump site that island makes!
Report
The opinions expressed here are those of the individual and not those of StreetAdvisor.
Uraniumfish 2yrs+
Secede or no, we retain the right to belittle them every chance we get...
Report
The opinions expressed here are those of the individual and not those of StreetAdvisor.
uptowngirl 2yrs+
Have never really stepped foot on Staten Island though have ridden the Staten Island Ferry a couple of times with visitors to show them the view of lower Manhattan. According to me its one of the best free attractions that we have in NYC.
Report
The opinions expressed here are those of the individual and not those of StreetAdvisor.
Uraniumfish 2yrs+
Hear hear, uptowngirl. There are also some interesting characters among the regulars who perform during the ferry rides for spare change. Not always the highest quality, but definitely charming entertainment. I imagine also a nice thing for the commuters, a little liveliness before the office work ahead.
Report
The opinions expressed here are those of the individual and not those of StreetAdvisor.
BroadwayBK 2yrs+
I've only ever driven though Staten Island, but I imagine that they have some affordable rents down there, though with good reason.
Report
The opinions expressed here are those of the individual and not those of StreetAdvisor.
hhusted 2yrs+
It is hard to say. Was Staten Island here before all the other boroughs? Was it here before Queens and Long Island were formulated as land plots? Interesting questions. I know there are a lot of Jews and Italians that live there. With the influx of immigrants to this city, I would not hesitate to guess that many different kinds of ethnic groups live there now.

I read somewhere that NYC wanted to be an independent state a few years back. I don't know how true that is, but at one time they were considering it.
Report
The opinions expressed here are those of the individual and not those of StreetAdvisor.

Add a comment

Best Neighborhoods to Live In

Best Cities to Live In

Tell everyone what you love about your neighborhood!

Leave a Review

Have a question?

How are schools? Is the area safe? What about public transit options?" Why not ask our community of locals!

Ask Now

Selling or Renting Your Home?

Maximize the selling price of your home by sharing what you love about your suburb to increase its appeal...

Leave a Review

Corporate Relocation Manager?

Enable your employees to share local knowledge in a private, trusted environment with those relocating... while building community.

Learn More